Canadians Receiving Healthcare In The United States

Along with the highly publicized 2005 case of Shona Holmes, who campaigned against the Canadian healthcare system on behalf of the Americans for Prosperity’s PAC from 2009 through 2012, there have been other high-profiled incidents in which Canadian politicians have visited the Mayo Clinic and other highly specialized hospitals in the United States. Media reports about Robert Bourassa, the premier of Quebec in 1994, then Prime Minister Jean Chrétien‘s visit to the Mayo Clinic in 1999, then Liberal MP Belinda Stronach‘s visit to the Mayo in 2007, and then Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Danny Williams have been criticized for being cynical, ironic, hypocritical, and/or elitist.

Prime Minister Jean Chrétien traveled to the Mayo Clinic twice in 1999 for medical care. Chrétien allegedly kept the visits a secret, with one occurring during a publicly announced ski trip to Vancouver.Canadian Liberal MP Belinda Stronach went to the United States for breast cancer surgery in June 2007. Stronach’s spokesperson Greg MacEachern was quoted in the article saying that the U.S. was the best place to have this type of surgery done. Stronach paid out-of-pocket for the surgery. Stronach had stated in an interview that she was against two-tier health care.

When Robert Bourassa, the premier of Quebec, needed cancer treatment, he went to the U.S. to get it. In 2010, Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Danny Williams travelled to the U.S. for heart surgery.

The Role Of Private Industry And Competition In Health Care

Private industry plays a role in both the US and Canadian health care systems, just in different ways.

The United States health care system:

Private enterprises are the primary providers of both health care insurance and health care services in the US. Insurers compete for customers, selling insurance policies to employers as benefits packages for employees or selling health care insurance policies directly to individual consumers. Health care providers compete for patients, often through areas of medical specialty, quality, or cost.

Individual consumers have influence in this market, but it can be limited. Their choices are often constrained by the types of services covered by insurance providers, the types of insurance benefits employers negotiate, or the doctors available within the insurance providers network of physicians.

The Canadian health care system:

Most health care services are provided by private providers, rather than federal or provincial providers. This means that doctors and physicians work independently in private practice, or are employed by private hospitals or private health service management organizations. Rather than being paid through claims made through private insurers, they derive much of their revenue by billing government health insurance.

Theres A Plandirect Insurance Plan For Everyone Whats Your Current Situation

You can tailor your coverage to include a range of healthcare needs, such as:

Your monthly premium will depend on the plan you choose. To get a quote and explore all our plans have to offer take our questionnaire.

With health and dental insurance, you pay a monthly premium which covers either entirely or to a certain percentage or annual maximum eligible costs that you would have otherwise paid out-of-pocket.Heres how costs could compare if youre paying for some common things without insurance vs how much you would pay for eligible out-of-pocket if you were covered by our popular CorePlus plan, for example.Note: For dental, this assumes the $25 person per calendar year deductible has been satisfied.

Don’t Miss: Do Part Time Starbucks Employees Get Benefits

Hospitals And Clinics In Canada

Most hospitals and clinics in Canada are government-funded and regulated, although there are some private clinics that offer specialised treatments. Major cities such as Toronto and Vancouver have well-equipped teaching hospitals linked to universities. However, finding an emergency department in rural parts of Canada may require a long drive. General family clinics can handle minor emergencies and are easily found throughout the country.

While the standard of care at public facilities in Canada is good, waiting times can be a problem and delays are common, even at an emergency department. To see a specialist, patients generally need a referral from a GP.

Is It Compulsory To Have Health Insurance In Canada

Canadas universal health-care system If youre a Canadian citizen or permanent resident, you may apply for public health insurance. With it, you dont have to pay for most health-care services.All provinces and territories will provide free emergency medical services, even if you dont have a government health card.

You May Like: How Long Do Health Benefits Last After Quitting

What Are The Benefits Of Private Healthcare In Canada

• If its a case of choosing between a personal health insurance plan and your companys group health insurance plan, it can often be better value to go it alone. Be sure to investigate what your employer is offering, and find out exactly what youll be paying for it. Amanda Frank goes into more detail here.
• Youll avoid the lengthy waiting times associated with Medicare. Having to wait for treatment is at best a huge inconvenience, and at worse a very serious issue.
• You wont be subject to the restrictions of some provincial health insurance plans. Most provinces/territories only support residents within their own borders, meaning if you end up in an accident outside of your home region, youll have to pay up. Private medical cover means you wont have to foot bills in other parts of the country.
• Its likely youll be able to stay in private rooms, and in nicer hospitals.
• Most importantly, youll have peace of mind that you have an extra safety net.

Gender Gap In Healthcare

Disparities between men and women’s access to healthcare in Canada have led to criticism, especially regarding healthcare privatization. While most healthcare expenses remain covered by Medicare, certain medical services previously paid for publicly have been shifted to individuals and employer-based supplemental insurance. While this shift has affected both genders, women have been more affected. Compared to men, women are generally less financially stable, and individual payments are a greater burden. Furthermore, many women work part-time or in fields that do not offer supplemental insurance, such as homemaking. As such, women are less likely to have private insurance to cover the costs of drugs and healthcare services.

The shift from public to private financing has also meant additional labor for women due to families relying on them as caregivers. Less public financing has shifted care to women, leaving “them with more support to provide at home.”

Women’s additional healthcare requirements, such as pregnancy, further exacerbate the gender gap. Despite comprising approximately half of Canada’s population, women receive the majority of Canadian healthcare.

Read Also: Starbucks Benefits For Part Time Employees

How To Buy Health Insurance

If youve settled on a private insurance provider for yourself and/or family, then its a fairly straightforward process from there.

You could simply access an insurers website and register with them for quotes and plans tailored to you. Since so much is done online these days, insurance companies have made it easy to get a lot of information and start registering without even having to speak with a customer representative.

However, if you need to speak to a representative to discuss your options, you can easily get in touch with one.

You should also be upfront about your medical history and possible pre-existing conditions when filling out the insurers questionnaire. Not doing so is fraud and you can end up in a lot of legal trouble and even be uninsurable.

Plans Are Provided By Green Shield Canada

You are eligible to apply for SureHealth insurance plans as long as you are a Canadian resident, you have valid provincial health insurance plan coverage , and you are under 80 years of age.

*Acceptance is guaranteed upon GSC’s receipt of initial payment.

Coverage amounts shown are in Canadian dollars.

Rates and/or benefits are subject to change GSC will provide policy owners with thirty days written notice.

This is not a contractThis is a summary and does not constitute a contract. Actual terms, conditions, limitations and exclusions are detailed in the contract issued by Green Shield Canada upon application approval. Reimbursement will be made for reasonable and customary eligible expenses incurred, paid for and received by the covered person, provided such services and supplies are, in the opinion of GSC, medically necessary for the treatment of an illness or injury, taking all factors into account.

For Quebec residentsTo be eligible for LINK or ZONE prescription drug coverage, you must be covered by the RAMQ plan. Your prescription drug claims must be submitted to RAMQ first. When RAMQ reimburses a portion of the drug cost, unpaid balances will be co-ordinated so that you may be reimbursed up to 100% of the eligible expense incurred. If the drug is not covered by RAMQ, the standard co-pay applies.

Inkblot therapyis provided by Inkblot Technologies Inc. Inkblot is a trademark of Inkblot Technologies Inc.

Read Also: Part Time Starbucks Benefits

Healthcare Spending By Province

The planning and funding of most publicly insured health services are the responsibility of provinces and territories. There is a regional variation in health system characteristics.

Healthcare costs per capita vary across Canada with Quebec and British Columbia at the lowest level and Alberta and Newfoundland at the highest.

Total health spending per resident varies from $7,378 in Newfoundland and Labrador to $6,321 in British Columbia. Public drug spending increased by 4.5% in 2016, driven largely by prescriptions for tumor necrosis factor alpha and hepatitis C drugs.

According to a 2003 article by Lightman, “In-kind delivery in Canada is superior to the American market approach in its efficiency of delivery.” In the US, 13.6 percent of GNP is used in medical care. By contrast, in Canada, only 9.5 percent of GNP is used on the Medicare system, “in part because there is no profit incentive for private insurers.” Lightman also notes that the in-kind delivery system eliminates much of the advertising that is prominent in the US and the low overall administrative costs in the in-kind delivery system. Since there are no means tests and no bad-debt problems for doctors under the Canadian in-kind system, doctors billing and collection costs are reduced to almost zero.

Do We Have Private Hospitals In Canada

There are over 100 private clinics across Canada that are typically run independently by physicians/surgeons who charge patients hundreds or thousands of dollars for procedures in their facilities.This blog post covers why some people are choosing private clinics over healthcare covered by insurance.

Recommended Reading: Does Medicare Pay For Maintenance Chiropractic Care

Physiotherapy Occupational Therapy And Massage Therapy

Coverage for services by physiotherapists, occupational therapists and Registered Massage Therapists varies by province. For example, in Ontario the provincial health plan, OHIP, does cover physiotherapy following hospital discharge and occupational therapy but does not cover massage therapy. To be eligible for coverage for physiotherapy in Ontario, the insured individual has to have been discharged as an inpatient of a hospital after an overnight stay and require physiotherapy for the condition, illness or injury for which he or she was hospitalized, or be age 19 or younger or age 65 or older.

Consider Getting Private Medical Insurance

If you’re unhappy with your Medicare options or aren’t able to work with the doctors you want to, private medical insurance might be great for you. Consider your family history, your budget, and the options for doctors in your area before you decide.

If you’re still trying to decide which private medical insurance is right for you and your family, contact us. We want you to feel like you’re covered for anything that comes your way.

Read Also: Starbucks Partner Health Insurance

So Is Healthcare In Canada Any Good

Compared to the standard of healthcare in the US, yes Canadas is very good. Canadians spend less per capita than their American neighbours, while performing far better for a bunch of factors, such as life expectancy, infant mortality, obesity rates, and so on.

On a global level, Canadas healthcare system performs fairly well. In 2019, the Lancets worldwide effective healthcare coverage index gave Canada a score of 90 out of 100 points much higher than the USs score of 82.

However, waiting times are a weak point for Canadian Medicare. A study by the Fraser Institute found that the median wait time for medically necessary treatment in 2019 was 20.9 weeks 124% longer than the median wait time in 1993 , when the annual study began.

As in 2019, nearly one in five Canadians report having to wait at least four months for elective surgery.

Did you know?

The three provinces with the highest number of hospitals are:

Box 41 Canada Health Act National Standards For Full Federal Transfer

To be eligible for the full federal transfer, a provincial public insurance plan must conform to each of the following five Canada Health Act principles:

Accessibility: the plan must not impede, either directly or indirectly, whether by charges made to insured persons or otherwise, reasonable access to insured health services.

Comprehensiveness: the plan must cover medically necessary physician and hospital services, including surgicaldental services that require a hospital setting.a

Universality: the plan must cover all provincial residents on uniform terms and conditions.b

Portability: the plan must not impose a minimum period of residence in excess of 3 months for new residents, it must cover its own residents when temporarily in another province and during the waiting period in another province for residents who have moved permanently.

Public administration: the provincial plan must be administered and operated on a non-profit basis by a public authority.

Notes:

a Insured services exclude services covered by the workers compensation system, which are financed through employer contributions to the workers compensation fund.

b The insured population excludes certain subgroups such as members of the military, Royal Canadian Mounted Police, prisoners and aboriginals, who are covered by the federal government.

Recommended Reading: Does Kroger Give Employee Discounts

How Does Canada Compare

Private health care spending is a higher proportion of overall health care spending in Canada than in many other comparable countries. Mark Stabile, Director of the School of Public Policy and Governance at the University of Toronto says that with the system that we have set up in Canada, which systematically excludes prescription drugs it is no surprise that there is going to be a large private component of health spending. Stabile notes that other health care systems such as the United Kingdom do have parallel private systems. However, they tend to be small. Stabile describes these parallel private systems as focused on a small number of clients and doing a small number of things noting that it is unlikely that you will get open heart surgery in a private system because its not going to make them money.

The mix of what is paid for publicly and privately in Canada differs from comparable countries. The table below provides a snapshot of health services that are paid for publicly and privately in Canada, the United Kingdom, France, New Zealand and the United States.

Do Health Insurance Policies Change Depending On The Province

Yes. Each of Canadas ten provinces and three territories offers its own public insurance plan. Some are significantly different. All offer basic health care services. Beyond this basic care, some are more generous than others. As a result, private health insurance policies are also different between provinces and territories.

Try our free health insurance comparison tool to get personalized quotes in just seconds.

Recommended Reading: Evolve Health Insurance

Why Reform Is Hard In Both Countries

As the U.S. entered lockdown under coronavirus, Sen. Bernie Sanders announced on April 8 that he had pulled the plug on his presidential run. A week later he endorsed former Vice President Joe Biden. After contests in 28 states and two territories, his path to winning the Democratic nomination had narrowed significantly despite an early edge. The next month, in a gesture designed to appeal to Sanders heartbroken supporters, Biden announced plans to expand Medicare. His campaign has proposed offering every American a new choice, a public health option like Medicare to make insurance more affordable.

As Potter watches COVID-19 rage in the U.S., the former health care communications executive said Americans live in fear of having big out-of-pocket bills without assurance that well have our expenses covered. With the number of uninsured Americans nearly double what they were before novel coronavirus, according to some estimates, Potter said that is not sustainable. In the latest PBS NewsHour-Marist poll, 56 percent of Americans think the U.S. response to the coronavirus pandemic was below average, if not the worst, in the world.

READ MORE: Is U.S. health care the best or least effective system in the modern world?

But if that happens, he said, the same private health insurance system that paid him to lie will reignite misinformation campaigns and fight hard to keep what it has.

Cost Of Having A Baby In Canada

While giving birth in Canada for citizenship is a major plus, there is also a downside of having a baby in Canada as a foreigner: cost. If you are giving birth in Canada as a permanent resident or are a citizen, you are completely covered through Canadaâs universal healthcare system. Your delivery will be free unless you opt for a private room, which could be a couple of hundred dollars unless it is covered by some sort of supplemental insurance you may have. The average stay for a new mom after delivery is two to three days. If she had a C-section, the stay increases to four days.

If you are giving birth in Canada without health insurance and without permanent resident status, be prepared to pay out of pocket. A regular delivery can be anywhere between 5,000 CAD to 8,000 CAD . If you require a C-section, it can cost between 10,000 and 12,000 CAD .

The following is a breakdown of some other baby-related costs if you plan on giving birth in Canada as a non-resident with no international insurance:

ServicePrice CAD Prenatal doctor visit100-150 Prenatal ultrasound300-500 Home birth and delivery with a midwife2,500

Recommended Reading: Asares Advanced Fingerprint Solutions